The Flipside

Then there is the not so great fantasy.

  
I just don’t think I can do high fantasy anymore. And this isn’t even it in its most purest form because there are portals from the fantasy land to the world as we know it.

I must have like the first story in this series though, Daughter of Smoke and Bone, because I did by this sequel. Though it has been sitting in my shelf for about a year I think. And I won’t be buying the third in the trilogy to see how it all ends because I just don’t care.

Some of the concepts in this series are good. I like the resurrecting, and the mysterious far off land they introduced in this book, but overall there is just too much gore. And not enough explaining. I don’t get why the two different peoples are fighting so much, I don’t get why they want to take over earth, I don’t really see where it could be headed, there doesn’t seem to be a solution to the problem the author has posed. Or at least not one I want to read about.

What is good about these books though is that the love story is not the focus as it is in so much fantasy. It’s important, but more important are the ideas of hope and peace. But that is also one of the problems with the series. I don’t really care about the peace because I haven’t been given enough information/back story to care and so without romance, there is nothing tying me to the characters. I guess it’s just really hard to empathise with them. Perhaps because they are not human.

And that’s another problem with high fantasy, it’s mostly just doom and gloom and nobody gets what they want. Including the reader.

Advertisements

In case you didn’t know, Garth Nix is the greatest writer of all time

  

I could totally live in the Old Kingdom. Well, except for all the dead and demonic beings wandering around. 

The new cover art for The Old Kingdom books is not the best but really, it’s what’s on the inside that counts. So don’t go judging this one by its cover. They are too old school fantasy for my liking, I wish they’d stuck to the versions that were black with the symbols, but perhaps that was a different publisher.

This new novel comes after Clariel, and I think before Sabriel, but I am going to reread them all anyway, that is the power of Nix’s prose. It’s got all the best bits of fantasy; a little magic, a little romance, a very well thought out history and lore. And none of the bad bits; no overly long descriptions of scenery, no overly long journeying sequences and everything turns out right in the end.

Nothing I could write here though would do any of his novels justice. You just really, really, really have to read them.